Wednesday, August 10, 2016

Its not the Cows....



Crocodile tears are a metaphorical usage.  But some people shedding crocodile tears will put to shame even those prehistoric predatory beasts known for its stealth and ruthless predatory skills. In the battle field of Kurukshetra the most infamous treachery and untruth were enacted like seasoned thespians by folks who are even to this day considered noble and epitome of honesty and righteousness. Mr. Narendra Modi’s theatrics, the past week, in a well stage managed interactive session (as he wants us to believe) resembling the customary interactions of the US Presidents was something akin to the vile and perfidious innocence displayed by the Panadava clan and their interlocutor, modulator and cahoots- the Charioteer of Arjuna!

It took almost a year for this man Narendra Madhav Modi to utter one word on the barbarism of the Cow vigilantes who have been unleashed by his party and its ideologue parent body the Sangh. It was in September last that a depraved mob propelled by the very hideous ideology pedaled by the Sangh and the VHP set upon an old Muslim man in Dadri and lynched him allegedly because he retained in his house cow meat. The number of incidences that regularly followed this cannibalism of the nationalists was systematic and heinous. Muslims and Dalits were handpicked for thrashing and bludgeoning by these criminals. While Mr. Modi   jet -set across continents and shook hands with Presidents and Prime ministers, some of whom until a couple of years ago had branded him pariah and untouchable. He missed no photo opportunity, all well orchestrated by his PR Company. All the while Cow vigilantes ran amok and Kashmir burnt, with such atrocities inflicted on Kashmiris that pales what the Zionist state of Israel perpetrate in Palestine.

Finally when he spake in his sonorous yelping fashion, he spoke with riders and with contrived sincerity. He did not repudiate the cow vigilante goons in toto but selectively branded a few criminals who were hounding “Dalits”. The man who elevated sophistry into a craft and higher art form went on to say in a pleading voice ,”Shoot me if you want but spare the Dalits”.

What the heck is this guy, a reincarnation of Jesus of Nazareth? Or is he a 21 st century self advocate of vicarious redemption of sorts? He has clearly questioned the faculty of the average Indian. It is true that a chief executive may not necessarily have to be involved in subjects that fall under the purview of States such as law and order. But these incidences were not trivial. In any case it is incumbent upon the Central government to monitor the law and order in States. For a Prime minister to claim that killing and daily persecution of Dalits & Muslims by cow protection group which is necessarily a bunch of thugs and urchins owing allegiance to his party, the RSS and VHP is not a matter within his purview is willful  dereliction of responsibility.

What I intend to take umbrage here is that, firstly in no uncertain words he alluded that Cow vigilantes are people with his and his governments ( meaning the RSS’s) patronage , though a few criminals may have infiltrated. It is they he asserts who cannot be tolerated. Meaning the ex officio cow vigilantes will be let loose. Then his very specious pleading,”don’t shoot the Dalit, shoot me instead if you must”.  I feel total revulsion at this remonstration of the man, the messiah for the many asinine middle class Indians. If there is unfeigned and an uncompromising will, what will it take him and his government  to unequivocally clamp down on these criminals, these savages of the VHP, Bajrang Dal and the Sangh   who pose as cow protectors?  Five minutes! The law of the land is absolutely clear as to how criminality must be confronted and put down. Why prevaricate and bay? But he has not moved a finger since the Dadri in September last, while letting loose the Sadhvis and his party members who went ranting their feral and dangerous invective on Dalits and Muslims.
Thirdly, when he pleaded to shoot him and not the Dalits, he conveniently ignored the atrocities on Muslims who for generations have been eking livelihood from leather processing and trade in leather. His Sanghi bred detestation for Muslims was blatantly manifest in his silence on lynching and hounding of Muslims in the name of cow protection. His government’s unpardonable indifference and disastrous engagements in Kashmir is yet another proof of this. That State is as good as lost- lost because a generation of young has been permanently alienated; and when one’s future looks bleak & hopeless , desperation naturally kicks in. This is what we see in Kashmir today.

Where do we position ourselves as a society and as a country with an elected chief executive who is specious in his utterances, who is unconcerned about the heinous practice of un-touchability and plight of Dalits, who harbours total disdain for Muslims and a general apathy and intolerance towards dissent?

Successive Congress governments beginning with that of Indira Gandhi’s have played the religion & caste card and ensured that fault lines and divisiveness became permanent feature of the polity. Mr. Modi has taken over from there and given a newer meaning to divide and rule and to ushering in a RSS dictated Indianness by distancing Dalits and Muslims from the national milieu. His cow vigilantism is solely orchestrated towards this end.


Modi is no Nelson Mandela. In fact even a remote attempt at comparison is offensive to the late icon of African resistance. When South Africa was tethering at the precipice of disintegration and racial violence soon after the dismantling of apartheid, a Modi would have doubly ensured that the natives or the majority blacks were let loose on the Afrikaners and eventually made a dystopian waste land of South Africa. What we need today is the man of the hour,  a person with vision who can like Nelson Mandela bring about reconciliation and oneness;  understand that a multicultural and diverse India is as rainbow a country like South Africa.  History can be a tool to reconcile and also to ensure that history doesn’t repeat. But for that we need a leader with character and the lack of it is what we have to bemoan.

4 comments:

rudraprayaga said...

Yesterday I had gone through this article, but want of time permitted me not to write my views here.

The exact hands behind all these barbarianism are not known well. In the name of Hindu radicals antisocial elements have cropped up to spoil the calm of innocent people.To an extent the former ones may be exhibiting their muscle power,I agree. There are very poor innocent ones among the minorities and Dalits and that too I second.But the so called upper caste is no exception to poverty and suffering and at the same time some powerful upper caste show no hesitation to intimidate the lower caste.

But all these loutish ways of hurting the defenceless are not solely done by the Hindutva fans.The media do not lag behind in adding chilly to make the situation hot. Without probing into the realities they jump to conclusion that results in a caste/religion based divide among the people.

And the beneficiaries of nearly six decades' dynasty where nepotism is in its peak,try to create turmoil to wipe away Modi and his group from the scene. They are playing with the life of innocent toothless man.The followers of that party have slavery in their blood and hence they cannot rise to the level of leaders.

Terrorism on the pillar of extremism has taken a new step of conversion from other religions and victimise the converts to be suicide squads.But their crime is not much attended to.

The others other than those extremist wolves, even their own kin are very compassionate and helpful people.What to do? In the name of a few hooligans straight thinking people also suffer.

I don't think Mr.Modi has given coaching to his men in troubling and punishing the toothless.The messes are in fact the productivity of power mongers.So they fabricate ugly ways and means to get into power.

In 1947 people had gone to the level of throwing unholy substances to their holy vicinity provoking their own people to rise against the opponents. Such filthy games prevailed among people from time immemorial and still prevails and will prevail also.That much dirty is human mind.

But you have given enough elaboration to justify your views and this is my view.None can say which is which because we don't witness anything.

Regarding Pandavas and Kauravas,I like to go with Lord Krishna and think that he was just because he tried all means to avoid a battle between the two.

Very nicely worded article as always.

Loco mente said...

Well, all I can say is when leadership and politics become one, there is little scope for reconciliation and revolution. I dont really follow politics and so I am not sure about the background... All I can say is that the image was equally disturbing and terrifying. Preach humanity!

Haddock said...

Like Rudraprayaga said, there is something more sinister going on than what we see, and for some reason the authorities are not stepping in to stop this.
A shame for our country.

Musings said...
This comment has been removed by the author.