Friday, September 9, 2011

Escape to Dreamland



Raman Menon hailed from a well-respected family of upper-caste Nairs in the erstwhile princely state of Cochin. The aristocracy that Menon clans among Nairs claim is more self-proclaimed than bestowed by extraterrestrial largesse or former princes. They resemble the British aristocracy of India, with their stiff upper lip and a “Gallic” or even haughty nose up in the air. They seem to believe in and convey the spirit of pristine Nair heritage and culture.

But Raman Menon cared little for the trappings of his surname. He was an ambitious and fun-loving person. Holding a respected position in the state bureaucracy, combined with his family’s lineage and social standing, he was poised to soar to greater heights. Young, handsome, and with masculine charm, he seemed destined for success.

He married into a family of Menons from Palghat, in the erstwhile Madras Presidency. The bride was a well-educated, sophisticated woman, an epitome of haute couture and an alumna of Yale in the USA. But this alliance was perhaps a serious misstep in the course of Raman Menon’s life. The incompatibility of the relationship led Mr Menon to file for divorce after much acrimony. The marriage ended with the same intensity with which it began. The stress of the divorce and its aftermath left Mr Menon drained. The marriage lasted about a year—a year of utmost turmoil.

Determined not to be left searching for a compatible partner, the Menon family arranged another bride for the young man—a distant cousin. Raman Menon married again. But ill fortune shadowed him like a relentless spectre; tragedy struck as nothing else could. The bride died less than six months into the marriage, succumbing to lymphoma. It was darkness at noon. Raman Menon’s life was shattered, his rising professional trajectory twisted like a mangled ladder. He was at a loss to pick up the threads once more. Cruel innuendos circulated, speculating about his ill luck and why fate seemed to deny comfort or longevity to any woman who became his consort.

He vanished from society and from the country. Settling in a foreign land, he never returned to the town of his birth. Once an agnostic, he became a theist and joined a Hindu religious outfit. He spent all his leisure time outside work at the ashram, adopting the name Sudhama. He lived frugally, walking about like an ascetic. Unlike fellow members of the congregation, who saw their involvement as a cherished luxury, Raman Menon was hermitic. He ate the simple food devotees brought. While travelling, he walked great distances like a nomad, subsisting on morsels from compassionate strangers. He resembled Jain monks on their long road to what they believe is nirvana and salvation. Rarely did he open up, but when he did, it was to confide that this life at the ashram was his dream and a calling.

A man who once professed agnostic beliefs, struck by successive tragedies, turned into a hermit and ascetic! A man who harboured utopian fantasies and dreams of living! Though this story is real, the tragic events in his life serve as a metaphor for the challenges we all face at different times. For less fortunate souls, the tempest lingers longer. Tragedy need not be overt but may manifest as dejection, disgust, frustration, or devastation—anything potent enough to persistently stress us. Then comes the time for wool-gathering, hoping for bliss and mirth in pursuits we once loved. For some, it sparks a frantic search for an escape route.

There is indeed a life out there, as I mentioned in the post “The Road Not Taken,” that beckons but is no longer mine. When it mattered, when I could have trodden that road, I did not—out of conditioning and unawareness of its pathos. I feel awed and envious of friends and ordinary people who, despite constraints, have achieved the extraordinary. They have not taken the cowardly path of an ill-clad, unwashed, smelly absconder claiming abstinence, nor are they escape artists who could outshine Houdini. Instead, within the bounds of social living, they have embraced the life of the liberated wanderer—like birds that transcend land and sea to migrate—embarking on occasional journeys of bliss and mirth to the dream that is Zion, a traveller’s Zion.

But alas, man often fails to see the paradise at hand that could lend wings to fly towards his fantastic dreams. Only when he knows what it is for a paradise to be lost shall he see the beacon that was always alight.



13 comments:

Mélange said...

Well Anil,I must say this is such a multi-layered subject which we can't come into a conclusion narrating a story or experience and so on.A subject completely personal and relative.Like the one in Chinthavishtayaya Syamala'.Whoever Menon he is,It's his idea,completely his own.People may vary completely depending upon the experiences,situations,age and all.

There was this girl of 16 who couldn't come into terms with what Siddhartha done to Yasodhara to get enlightened.Anyway from a woman's point of view she had different conclusions which finally made her write a poem called "Yasodhara".Now after decades,she thinks it need lot of courage and reasoning to get out of luxury and subtlety surrounding us,and so Poor Sidhartha can be spared.She sometimes gaze at what she wrote.She then realises that too was a state of mind converted into a poem,of hers.

Whatever path a person choose,if we are into judgement,it will definitely be about the person who has chose the same.The person brings a certain level of definition to what he write and choose.Sometimes we need to go beyond words,ideas,religions and isms to see what the person is into.

He who knows and knows that he knows is a wise,follow him..

Balachandran V said...

He who knows not and knows not he knows not...

Sandy said...

I must be looney here...Again, I will try to leave a comment...I like your story, "Escape to Dreamland". It's a bit sad in that I think his mind became bitter and maybe a bit twisted; he found himself with some pretty serious moves in life...

anilkurup59 said...

@ Melange

-I appreciate your eloquent comment on the post.
The Post just came to my mind because I got a call from the protagonist in the anecdote and also was at the same time mulling over how ideas surge in us proportional to the state of mind. This, I wonder if some one will deny. John Milton's "Paradise Lost"was I gather a direct cause of his state of mind. This goes especially with poetry.

Coming to lay people like you me and any other , we are influenced in our word, deed and letter we pen by our moods. I'm sure a happy merry moments will not evoke passion for penning a poem on agony or melancholia .

The person I referred to in my post and the fictional character in the film may be related and not. I do not think that we could presume that it depends upon as you said, age , character etc before coming to conclusion. We are discussing not concluding..

It is in fact a bizzaire route taken to what is perceived as comfort and peace.A morphine.Deluding into an illusion.

What could happen if frustrations and setbacks over power our faculties.People do react differently.But is it alright to wish away such reactions as corollary ,triggered by ones own ideas, experience , situations age etc.And it will defy logic and substance?
We can attribute a similar alibi to a felon as well?

Siddartha's case was a classic example that dosen't fit in here His renunciation was at the prime of his youth when life was blooming personally. But he saw a wider picture of the world and life. And that brought forth some golden age in Philosophical thought. How can we compare his decision and the consequence with you, me or anybody escaping from reality to cocoon in some place?

Ha you said it - the poem Yashodara was written from a given state of mind.

There is nothing here to say that this person chose something beyond isms. I would like to see if there is any realm beyond all that as you suggest. Experiences may mellow some and make some bellicose, make some enfeeble , others determined. The choice is ours.

anilkurup59 said...

@ Balan


A tooter who tooted a flute
Tried to tutor two tutors to toot
Said the two to the tooter
Is it harder to toot or
To tutor two tutors to toot?

Do you make anything out of this?

anilkurup59 said...

@ Sandy,
Thanks for the comment. I do not think you are looney.
In fact I wonder if it is me who is a looney or some other when I see similar people and such reactions.

Yes in way you are right , bitterness too can bring-forth strange thoughts and actions

Kavita Saharia said...

Sorry Anil , i am not sure if i really understand this but after reading it several times here are my thoughts-- Living is an art and escape to dreamland is an option too.

anilkurup59 said...

@ Kavita,

I thank you for the patience you exercised.
I can only laugh about myself. However I feel that the comment which Melange posted and the reply I pasted perhaps tells a bit more .
I endorse without demure your statement, "Living is an art and escape to dreamland is an option too".

Mélange said...

Experiences may mellow some and make some bellicose, make some enfeeble , others determined. The choice is ours."-This is fine.What I was trying to mention is,when it comes to judgement (which we only do if it comes to our 'circle'),we may have to consider what a 'person' you are goin to judge about.It's not about escaping Anil.It's about understanding to me.Rest is known.

How can we compare his decision and the consequence with you, me or anybody escaping "-Dear Anil,for me it's not about escaping.Escaping is not spiritual.It's a different plight,I think we can discuss in some other occasion.But when it comes to Sidhartha,still we may have many other perspectives,many to come yet from generations to follow.I personally think at least a small percentage among us,is going through similar mindset (Sidhartha being away from the common lot and witnessing the pains at last)in a given time.Some may carry that with them even while they are into the so called material life.Most have disappointment why they couldn't follow where as few admit that they didn't had the courage to do so.Still I find it valuable as a person.

(I am of no opinion that Lord Buddha had something new there as a philosophy.When we go deeper,no philosopher whether he is Sidhartha,Jiddu or Osho have come up with completely fresh,since it's all there in our roots.Being our own respo,we might not be able to go through and analyse what's suitable for us.Being not semitic, we are not compelled to learn.Sidhartha's situations gave him a chance.So there's nothing wrong in comparisons for a genuine mind Anil-(I know this is again another topic,sorry that it's all inter-connected in a way.)

Thank you for always coming up with something rational.Cheers !

Insignia said...

Anil,

Read this post thrice :) Humans are so complicated to understand.

I think I understood partially after reading the comments here except for Balan's and your response to him :)

Maybe the tragedy that struck the person back to back realigned his belief, make him realize purpose in life and so on?

He chose a path which might give him an escape route from his drudgery and has found solace. Thats how he could handle it. If it were you or me; maybe we would have chosen some other path.

Life - he is living it on his terms.

anilkurup59 said...

@ Melange

The first para of “understanding the others judgement” – if the judgement or the action of a person is considered sacrosanct then there will be no room for debate and discussion. Because we consider the other inviolable.
The point here is spiritual escapism, though I intended to touch on the act of Houdini per se. Whether the escape route and the intended result are got is different matter. If questioned -it will be like did you get tipsy after consuming the spirit- the opium?
Since you seem to have been touched by Krishnamurthy and here is a short para of his, on the subject, “.....now what is the impetus behind the search for God, and is that search real? For most of us, it is an escape from actuality. So, we must be very clear in ourselves whether this search after God is an escape , or whether it is a search for truth in everything- truth in our relationships, I seeking God merely because we are tired of this world and its miseries then it is an escape route. Then we create God, and therefore it is not God. The God of the temple, of the books is not God; obviously it is a marvellous escape...”
And yet again, the story of Siddartha is incomparable with the story I mentioned. And there is nothing wrong in discussing an act , though each deed has a fertile ground to commit.
That is my take. Thanks that you enjoy the discussion.


@ Insignia,

B, now you too see the whole matter complicated. Tremendous patience to read it twice. I'm sorry .

Reminds me of Dale Carnegie who after publishing many books and essays on self improvement, living, positive mind and even analyzing and rubbishing the act of suicide as a cowardly escape, killed himself, if we believe one version related to his demise.Ironical indeed this life.!

Erratic Thoughts said...

Escaping to dreamland is a good option if its not running away from the situation at hand.The need to escape for some is the constant innuendos from the society and them reminding us about our frustrations,it can be very suffocating.You start questioning your own beliefs and it can get quite traumatic.
Making peace with the past could help,but it is indeed a slow process.

anilkurup59 said...

@ Erratic Thoughts,

One must have the courage to question ones belief. And must also have the strength to accept if ones belief is proved wrong. The trauma is more when one deludes into believing that the contrary to ones belief doesn't exist.
In fact hallucinating is a means to be free. That happens in all of us but in varying degrees.
Don't you think so?